What Are Good Feet Store Alternatives?

A Good Feet Store alternative refers to a company that operates in the same industry, manufacturing and selling arch supports, footwear, and foot care products, as the Good Feet Store. These alternatives offer similar value to customers at a lower cost.

Dr. Scholl’s, Spenco, and Superfeet are recognized as the primary alternatives to the Good Feet Store, as they provide comparable products at more affordable prices. Opting for competitors of the Good Feet Store offers several key advantages, including cost savings, a wider selection of products, better accessibility, and a more favorable return policy.

This article gives an overview of the Good Feet Store competitors (with prices and benefits), which include the following brands.

  • Powerstep
  • Dr. Scholl’s
  • Currex Runpro
  • Superfeet Green
  • Easyfeet Mount Strength
  • Happy Feet
  • Spenco
  • Birko-Flex Arch Support
  • New Balance Orthotic Inserts

1. Powerstep

PowerStep is a brand of orthotics designed by podiatrist Dr. Les Appel, offering affordable and custom-feel insoles without a prescription, based on his understanding of foot anatomy and passion for running. A 2016 study entitled “A comparison of different over-the-counter foot orthotic devices on multi-segment foot biomechanics” conducted by Reed Ferber at the University of Calgary compared the effects of different over-the-counter foot orthotic devices on foot biomechanics.

The study found that PowerStep, along with other over-the-counter devices, resulted in a decreased strain on the plantar fascia and reduced rearfoot eversion during walking compared to walking without orthotics. The study also noted that while all over-the-counter devices reduced plantar fascia strain to some extent, only PowerStep exhibited significant decreases in peak rearfoot eversion. However, none of the devices were found to reduce medial longitudinal arch deformation.

PowerStep is an alternative to Good Feet Store arch supports becasue it offers a significantly lower price range of $50-$70, which is approximately 80-90% less expensive than Good Feet insoles. Additionally, PowerStep stands out by providing various types of orthotics tailored to specific conditions such as Morton’s neuroma, plantar fasciitis, heel spurs, back pain, knee pain, or flat feet.

When asking about the brand reputation of Powerstep, we can refer to customer reviews on Trustpilot, illustrated below.

good feet store insole alternative powerstep
  1. Podiatrist Recommendation: One customer mentioned that their podiatrist recommended Powerstep after a foot injury, indicating that Powerstep may have a professional recommendation associated with it. In contrast, the Podiatrist reviews on The Good Feet Store seem to vary, including both positive and negative feedback.
  2. Effectiveness and Foot Problem Resolution: Customers praised the effectiveness of Powerstep inserts and mentioned that they helped resolve foot problems over time. One customer specifically mentioned that the Powerstep inserts were significantly more effective than the inserts that come with expensive shoe brands.
  3. Product Range: The customers mentioned purchasing various Powerstep products, such as Original, Pulse Max, Slimtech 3/4, and Fusion sandals. This suggests that Powerstep offers a diverse range of arch supports for different needs.
  4. Specific Condition Support: One customer stated that they found Powerstep to be excellent for their double bone spur condition. This implies that Powerstep offers arch supports designed to address specific foot conditions.

2. Dr. Scholl’s Custom Fit

Dr. Scholl’s is a well-known footwear and orthopedic foot care brand that originated in the United States and is now owned by Yellow Wood Partners. (Since 2021, global rights to the brand have been owned by investment firm Yellow Wood Partners through subsidiary Scholl’s Wellness Company, having purchased the North American rights from Bayer in North America in 2019, and the international rights from Reckitt in 2021.)

Dr. Scholl’s Custom Fit Insole is a personalized shoe insert that is tailored to individual feet. It is recommended through the use of a Custom Fit Kiosk that utilizes Footmapping technology to assess various parameters of the feet and provide tailored recommendations.

The main benefits of Dr. Scholl’s Custom Fit Insole include customized cushioning and support systems specific to an individual’s arch type, foot size, and weight. This helps improve foot stability, reduce stress on joints, and enhance overall comfort.

A 2019 study by Ryan T Lewinson from the University of Calgary compared biomechanical variables associated with running injuries between participants wearing regular athletic footwear and those wearing Dr. Scholl’s insoles. The study found that Dr. Scholl’s insoles reduced peak vertical loading rates (VLRs) by 16%, which is associated with plantar fasciitis.

Dr. Scholl’s Custom Fit Insole offers a cost-effective alternative to Good Feet Store arch supports, priced at $59.95–$65.95. This presents a significant saving of $349 compared to a pair of Good Feet Store arch supports. Additionally, Dr. Scholl’s Custom Fit Insole is both FSA and HSA-eligible, allowing users to potentially use their flexible spending or health savings accounts to cover their expenses. On the other hand, Good Feet Store insoles are not covered by FSA, HSA, or insurance, limiting the available options for reimbursement.

3. Currex Runpro

CURREX is a company that specializes in manufacturing shoe insoles, founded by Björn Gustafsson, a German triathlon world champion and has been developing professional motion analysis systems for athletes in various sports. CURREX RunPro is one of the insoles produced by CURREX, designed to reduce injuries and expedite recovery, allowing runners to continue their activities.

The Currex RunPro is a suitable alternative to Good Feet Store insoles becasue it provides extra padding in the heel, making it beneficial for individuals who tend to heel strike during running or walking. It also features a firm piece specifically designed for arch support, available in three different heights, which corresponds to the strengthener, maintainer, and relaxer options available at Good Feet Store.

The key benefits of Currex RunPro insoles are shown below.

currex runpro insoles good feet store arch support alternative
  • Increased comfort: The insoles offer enhanced comfort, providing a unique and secure wearing experience. They aim to optimize movement and improve overall comfort while running.
  • Faster regeneration: CURREX RunPro insoles aid in faster recovery after physical exertion. They contribute to the regeneration process, helping runners bounce back quicker.
  • Improved performance: These insoles are designed to enhance performance by optimizing foot movement and providing additional support and cushioning during the landing phase. They aim to maximize control and comfort while running.
  • Breathability and sweat absorption: CURREX RunPro insoles are designed with breathability in mind. They are constructed to absorb sweat, keeping the feet dry and comfortable during physical activity.

4. Superfeet Green

Superfeet is a company that specializes in providing foot pain relief and comfort through a wide range of over-the-counter orthotic devices and arch support insoles. Superfeet insoles have been recognized for their positive impact on foot health, providing relief from pain and receiving recommendations from podiatrists. They are effective in reducing strain on the plantar fascia and feature the patented Encapsulating Stabilizer System (ESS) for comprehensive foot support and stability.

A 2013 study published in the Journal of Physical Therapy Science entitled “Standing Balance on the Ground —The Influence of Flatfeet and Insoles” found that Superfeet insoles were effective in stabilizing standing balance on level ground for both flat-footed and normal-footed subjects. The insoles had lower total locus length values compared to other insoles and no insoles, indicating improved stability.

Superfeet Green offers valuable features that make it a suitable alternative to Good Feet Store arch supports like deep heel cup to enhance natural cushioning and the high arch shape for stabilizing the foot, and alleviating stress on the feet, ankles, knees, and back. And while it is a full-length insole, limiting its compatibility with certain types of shoes,  its price is competitive (€50.00 per pair, equivalent to approximately $59.00 USD), providing good value for the features it offers.

Based on customer reviews and comments from BBB and Trustpilot, Superfeet has received mixed feedback.

  • Positive Review: A customer purchased Superfeet insoles from a different online retailer but found them to be lacking in support. They reached out to Superfeet customer service, who confirmed that the insoles were counterfeit. The customer appreciated the assistance and expressed satisfaction with Superfeet’s helpfulness in addressing the issue.
  • Negative Review: On March 10, 2023, a customer placed an order for 4 pairs of Superfeet adapt run insoles. However, the package did not arrive by the expected delivery date of March 17. Despite contacting Superfeet customer support for assistance, the customer reported being met with unhelpful service. They expressed frustration and disappointment with the support team’s refusal to assist and perceived their response as attributing the issue to the customer’s fault.

5. Easyfeet Mount Strength

Easyfeet is a healthcare company that offers effective orthotic solutions for foot-related and common body alignment problems. The CEO and founder of Easyfeet is Anna Nikitina, who has been serving in the role since February 2018. Easyfeet Plantar Fascia 220 lb+ refers to the Mount Strength shoe insert. According to the company website, Easyfeet Mount Strength is a powerful orthotic designed to withstand weights of 220 pounds or more. The insert helps distribute body weight, protect the spine and joints, and is suitable for individuals over 200 lbs, 250 lbs, or even 300 lbs.

The main benefits of the Mount Strength orthotic inserts from Easyfeet include powerful high arch support, better body alignment, relief from pain conditions such as plantar fasciitis and metatarsalgia, and the ability to fit in various shoe types. These inserts utilize Anti-Pronation Technology, provide additional arch support, align the heel, knee, and spine, and offer cushioning and shock absorption for enhanced comfort.

Although Easyfeet Plantar Fascia 220 lb+ provide the same level of support as Good Feet, they are full-length inserts, so they cannot be worn in sandals, but they’re much easier to put in and take out (especially for older people). This makes them perfect for people who have trouble getting their inserts in and out properly. Easyfeet insoles are made from a variety of soft materials, including memory foam and EVA foam. This combination makes them comfortable and supportive. They also help distribute pressure evenly throughout your foot, which is helpful if you have flat feet or other foot issues.

Easyfeet distinguishes itself from the Good Feet Store by providing a default 1-year warranty and a 90-day full refund policy. In contrast, the Good Feet Store offers a store-credit return policy and a lifetime guarantee but at an additional cost of $1,000.

6. Happy Feet

HappyFeet is a company that specializes in health and comfort sandals, shoes, and insoles. Founded in 1985 by Michael Burch, they are the sole U.S. distributor of Kenkoh Health Sandals and offer a wide range of footwear brands, including Birkenstock, Finn Comfort, Aetrex, Dansko, Vionic, and Mephisto. HappyFeet shoe insoles, such as the Kenkoh or Lynco By Aetrex, feature rubber nodules that provide unique health benefits and are selected for their comfort and therapeutic qualities.

The benefits of HappyFeet insoles, according to a clinical study conducted at Sona Imaging Solutions, Inc. in Orange City, Florida, include increased venous circulation, reduced daily recovery time, and decreased pain in the lower extremities, as illustrated below.

what are the good feet store alternatives happy feet

The study, published in the Journal of the American Podiatric Medical Association and Applied Ergonomics, involved 30 volunteers aged 20-70 years who suffered from lower extremity or back pain. Venous Duplex Ultrasound findings showed an average increase of 53% in venous circulation with the use of HappyFeet® insoles. Furthermore, 96% of participants reported satisfaction with wearing the insoles, and 54% experienced a decrease in foot pain while using HappyFeet.

Happy Feet differs from Good Feet Store in that it serves as an aggregator of various insole brands, while Good Feet Store manufactures and sells its own arch supports. Happy Feet can be considered a viable alternative to Good Feet Store as it offers over-the-counter orthotics that provide similar benefits at a significantly lower cost, approximately one-fourth of the price.

7. Spenco

Spenco is an innovative healthcare company founded in 1967 by Dr. Wayman Spence, focused on producing high-quality insole and foot care products. Today, under the leadership of President and CEO Steven B. Smith, Spenco Medical Corporation has evolved into one of the world’s leading foot care brands, with products sold in over 84 countries. Their mission is to help people everywhere achieve greater comfort and improve their overall well-being through their quality products and exceptional customer service.

This table lists most of the types of insoles offered by Spenco.

Type of InsoleNames
Cushioning InsolesPolysorb Cross Trainer Insole, RX Heel Cushions, Total Support Gel Insole, Polysorb Heavy Duty Insole, Gel Heel Cups, Polysorb Walker/Runner Insole, RX Arch Cushions Insole
Stability InsolesGround Control Low Arch Insole, RX Orthotic Arch Insole, Total Support Gel Insole, RX Thinsole 3/4 Length Insole, RX Arch Cushions 3/4 Length Insole, Total Support Max Insole
Comfort InsolesFull Length Plantar Fascia Insole, Polysorb Walker/Runner Insole, Gel Heel Cups
Physician’s InsolesRX Heel Cushions, RX Comfort Insole, RX Orthotic Arch 3/4 Length Insole
Diabetic InsolesDiabetic Trim to Fit, Medics Diabetic+ Insole
Performance InsolesGround Control Low Arch Insole, Propel Performance Insoles, Propel + Carbon Performance Insoles

Spenco is a company known for producing high-quality products.

Spenco insoles have been designed by biomechanical experts for superior comfort and support. The contoured and supportive heel cup provides even more support, while the metatarsal pad ensures ideal foot alignment.

Carbon plate insoles are available for athletes and professionals who demand optimal performance on the pitch, as well as recreationally active people. Spenco’s website boasts many insoles ranging from cushioning, performance, and stability to comfort.

The Spenco Propel + Carbon Performance Insoles are priced at $99, which is a mere 25% of the cost of a pair of arch supports from the Good Feet Store, making it a viable alternative for those who are physically active. The insoles boast a unique construction, comprising memory foam, ethylene vinyl acetate, and carbon fiber. Spenco’s unwavering dedication to quality and innovation is evident in its exceptional products.

8. Birko-Flex Arch Support

The Birko-Flex Arch Support, produced by Birkenstock, is a moderate flange arch support crafted from washable EVA (Ethylene-Vinyl-Acetate) fabric. It provides exceptional durability against water, aging, and chemicals. With its anatomically shaped footbed, it is particularly suitable for sports shoes and work shoes, making it an ideal choice for individuals with low to average arch feet. The support includes a deep heel cup and metatarsal support, offering enhanced comfort and stability. Its waterproof, lightweight, and flexible design further contribute to its effectiveness.

Birkenstock is a renowned German shoe manufacturer recognized for its production of Birkenstocks, a popular brand of sandals and other footwear. The distinguishing feature of Birkenstock shoes is their contoured cork footbeds, crafted with layers of suede and jute, which adapt to the natural shape of the wearer’s feet. Birko-Flex Arch Support is an alternative to the Good Feet Store becasue they are half insoles, which can be placed in most footwear like dress shoes, tennis, shoes, boots, and sneakers. They are also significantly less expensive ($49.95 per pair).

When inquiring about the reputation of the Birkenstock brand, we can look at customer reviews on the Better Business Bureau, which are displayed below for reference.

Birko-Flex Arch Support Good feet Store Alternative
  1. Positive customer service experience: One customer had an excellent experience with Birkenstock’s customer service during the COVID-19 pandemic. They praised the helpfulness of the staff, particularly in processing returns and issuing refunds promptly. They expressed surprise at the negative reviews they had seen, as their personal experience was entirely positive.
  2. Negative experience with a return and customer service: Another customer had a negative experience when attempting to make a change to their order. They contacted Birkenstock shortly after placing the order but were informed that the shoes were already packaged for shipping and that no modifications could be made. The customer expressed disappointment with the lack of assistance and questioned the level of support provided by Birkenstock.
  3. Quality and workmanship concerns: One customer expressed dissatisfaction with the quality of the Birkenstock shoes they purchased. They specifically mentioned a pair of Arizona sandals where a nail popped out of the footbed. The customer contacted customer service and was disappointed with the response, claiming that Birkenstock did not guarantee their workmanship and did not seem to care about their customers. The lack of a warranty or guarantee for workmanship was seen as a significant drawback by this customer.

It is important to note that these reviews represent the experiences and opinions of a limited number of customers and may not reflect the overall sentiment of all Birkenstock customers.

9. New Balance Comfort Fit Insole

New Balance is a prominent sports footwear and apparel manufacturer that was founded in 1906 as the New Balance Arch Support Company. They are headquartered in Brighton, MA, Massachusetts, and have a significant manufacturing presence in the United States and the United Kingdom.

New Balance custom fit insole is an arch support available in 12 types for both men and women. It is made of 64% Polyurethane, 16% TPU/Nylon, 15% Fabric, and 5% Aqua Poron. The insole features specially placed Abzorb cushioning to protect the heel and forefoot from shock, air flow channels for temperature regulation, an extra deep heel cup for added support and comfort, and an anti-blister top cover.

The main benefits of New Balance custom fit insoles include shock absorption and cushioning for the heel and forefoot, improved air circulation to keep the feet cool, enhanced support and comfort with the extra deep heel cup, and protection against blisters with the anti-blister top cover.

Although the research on New Balance Insoles is limited, in a 2020 study by Elena Escamilla-Martínez from the University of Extremadura involving 33 male recreational runners, it was found that the New Balance® 738 running shoe effectively maintained the plantar pressure pattern in most zones, except the midfoot.

New Balance custom fit insole is a cost-effective alternative to Good Feet Store, priced at $59.99. While it is a full-length insole and does not specifically cater to orthopedic needs for conditions like plantar fasciitis, it offers a viable option for those seeking affordable arch support.

The popular Good Feet Store arch supports alternatives are listed below.

  • Redi-Thotics Flex Orthotic Insoles. Redi-Thotics are a popular choice as an alternative to arch supports from the Good Feet Store. These insoles are favored for their added cushioning and stability, which are recommended by podiatrists to alleviate foot pain. Unlike the arch supports from the Good Feet Store, Redi-Thotics feature a foam base and a plush top layer, providing enhanced comfort and support.
  • Dr. Marten’s Cushion Shoe Insoles. Specifically designed for Doc Martens, these insoles target those with a low arch, and (similarly to Good Feet insoles) aim to make the breaking-in period more comfortable.
  • Timberland Pro Anti-Fatigue Insoles. These insoles are designed specifically for work boots and athletic work shoes to address fatigue and relieve work-related symptoms.
  • Walkomfy Heavy Duty Insoles. Walkomfy Heavy Duty Insoles feature multiple layers, these insoles distribute body weight, relieve parts of the back, and ease leg and foot pain while walking.
  • Samurai Ninjas Insoles – Samurai Ninjas Insoles are a commonly chosen alternative to Good Feet insoles, mainly due to their lower price (under $30 USD). Crafted from durable hard plastic, these insoles are designed to alleviate leg and foot discomfort, relieving common problems like shin splints and plantar fasciitis.

What Arch Support Shoes Are Comparable To Good Feet Store?

The arch support shoes that are comparable to the Good Feet Store insoles include Rockport Let’s Walk Men’s Bungee, Birkenstock Arizona, Drew Women’s Antwerp, Brooks Adrenaline GTS 21, New Balance Fresh Foam 880v11, Saucony Guide 14, Hoka One One Bondi 7, Asics Gel-Kayano 28, and Teva Original Universal.

  • Rockport Let’s Walk Men’s Bungee: This walking shoe offers both comfort and arch support similar to Good Feet Store insoles, with a reinforced arch and shock-absorbing sole.
  • Birkenstock Arizona: A sandal with built-in arch support and a back strap to keep the foot in place, perfect for long-distance walks and summer holidays.
  • Drew Women’s Antwerp: A walking shoe with a reinforced arch and shock-attenuation materials in the sole, popular for hiking and sightseeing.
  • Brooks Adrenaline GTS 21: This top recommended sneaker for flat feet is both flexible and sturdy, according to customer reviews, making it perfect for active adventures.
  • New Balance Fresh Foam 880v11: Another Good Feet Store alternative shoe with built-in arch support, New Balance’s Fresh Foam line is a popular choice for those with flat feet.
  • Hoka One One Bondi 7: This running shoe has a wide base and maximum cushioning for those who need extra support.
  • Asics Gel-Kayano 28: Asics is another top-rated brand for those with flat feet, and the Gel-Kayano 28 offers both support and comfort.
  • Saucony Guide 14: Known for their supportive shoes, Saucony’s Guide 14 is a popular second choice for those in need of extra arch support and who don’t want to spend extra cash on Good Feet Store insoles.

How Much Do Good Feet Orthotics Cost?

The price of Good Feet Store arch support products typically falls between $200 and $500 per pair. They are available for individual purchase or as part of a multiple pair 3-Step system. For instance, a package of three pairs of Good Feet arch supports is priced at $1,299.

In Euros, the price range for Good Feet Store arch support products would be approximately 170 EUR to 425 EUR per pair, with the three-pair package costing around 1,105 EUR.

When comparing prices with other off-the-shelf orthotics, it’s important to note that off-the-shelf options generally have a lower price range, typically ranging from $20 to $150 per pair.